Bethesda Announces Backwards Review Policy

Bethesda Announces Backwards Review Policy

Bethesda has announced officially that it will only send out review copies of games to publications one day before release. They have been doing this since the release of DOOM, which was a critical success, but because of this policy speculation was rife about its quality.

They give their rationale as wanting everyone to experience their games at the same time. And that if people want to wait for reviews before they buy a game, then they should simply wait, as they don’t have to buy the game on release.

Both of these things are essentially true. However in practice, Bethesda is not sticking to them, and it does not work out that way.

For starters, Skyrim Remastered has been given to certain sites and ‘influencers’ before release. The problem being that their new policy is not a blanket one, they can easily give out codes and copies to publications they know will review them better than others, and leads to the undesirable possibility of the way games used to be reviewed in the early 2000’s, with publications essentially bidding on exclusive reviews much earlier than anyone else, leading to debacles such as Drivergate.

In addition, they have a special pre-order bonus letting you play the game a day early. That isn’t the same time for everyone then either.

The problem with this policy is mostly for the consumers and reviewers. They will be forced to get into companies good books to be chosen to get a code early, so that they can actually have something up on release of the game, as most people only read the earliest reviews before deciding if they should or shouldn’t purchase. This creates an imbalance in which reviewers are far more likely to want to impress the companies with great deals rather than reviewing the game honestly – which is bad for the average consumer expecting all reviews to be somewhat unbiased.

Of course, it’s the companies right to do this. These are their most prized assets after all. In the end it’s a bad omen for consumers and gaming publications, but Bethesda will probably do just fine. I don’t personally see this becoming a huge issue until they have some kind of scandal – a game that is awful upon release which everyone expected to be good and preordered without any reviews available, or even worse, false good reviews.

To read Bethesda’s statement, click here.

Related posts

Gone Home Dev Raises $15,000 for LGBT Rights

Gone Home Dev Raises $15,000 for LGBT Rights

The Fullbright Company, developer of Gone Home, has raised almost fifteen thousand dollars for LGBT rights organisation, Lambda Legal.

PSA: Batman Arkham Knight

PSA: Batman Arkham Knight

  This is a quick PSA, as today marks the release of Batman: Arkham Knight. The game is the latest in a long line to be marred by poor technical releases. The game comes locked natively at 30 frames per second, even on the highest set ups. This looks like a deliberate effort to keep...

Google Purchases Twitch for $1 Billion Dollars

Google Purchases Twitch for $1 Billion Dollars

For those of you unfamiliar, Twitch TV is a gaming stream platform that's rapidly become an essential pillar of the eSports and online gaming community. Gamers love Twitch because it allows viewers to tap into gaming as a spectator sport, often it becomes more about the personality and persona...

Transformable Optimus Prime/PS1, Megatron/Megadrive

Transformable Optimus Prime/PS1, Megatron/Megadrive

Sony Japan and Asia has just announced a new line of products, in collaboration with toy manufacturer Takara Tomy. Most of the line consists of scaled down miniature versions Playstation models, including the PS2, the PS3 and the PS4. More interestingly, the line also features an Optimus...

Nintendo Switch Dev Kits are only $450

Nintendo Switch Dev Kits are only $450

Nintendo Switch Dev Kits will be less than ten Percent the cost of the Wii U ones.

Nintendo Direct December 2013 – Super Smash Bros U, Hyrule Warriors and Reggie wrestling himself

Nintendo Direct December 2013 - Super Smash Bros U, Hyrule Warriors and Reggie wrestling himself

The Wii U huh? I can’t speak for the community at large, but I am still waiting for those killer apps. Super Smash Bros U may be enough to warrant a purchase alone, but we need to see more promise on the horizon. It is for this reason that I always get a little excited for Nintendo’s mini-press...

IGDA Names and Shames Online Harassers with the GG Autoblocker

IGDA Names and Shames Online Harassers with the GG Autoblocker

IGDA Names and Shames Online Harassers with the GG Autoblocker

Red Dead Redemption 2 Map Leaked (reportedly)

Red Dead Redemption 2 Map Leaked (reportedly)

Red Dead Redemption 2 Map has been leaked, according to various sources.

Civilization Online – This Is Not What I’m Used To

Civilization Online - This Is Not What I'm Used To

Civilization Online doesn't look like a traditional Civilization game.

Leave a Reply