Did Nintendo sell an illegal ROM?

Did Nintendo sell an illegal ROM?

Nintendo is incredibly heavy handed concerning emulation. They have a black and white view, to them it is absolute piracy and stealing, and they will quash any project within their remit that uses emulated assets, and they have often gone after rom distributors and hackers.

There is validity in their argument. The common rejection to Nintendo’s antics is that these gamers are old, nobody plays them anymore and they are hard to find. Nintendo would retort that they still sell a lot of these games, and are actively making money from their own intellectual property and products on their virtual console, NES Classic, and other such outlets.

This brings us to our next point. In a recent article by Eurogamer, they have uncovered evidence that shows Nintendo almost definetly downloaded a ROM from a website, then sold it back to us on the virtual console. They would of course be perfectly legally allowed to do this – it is still their product after all – but it brings up all sorts of questions on ethics.

Here’s how Eurogamer figured this out. In a homebrew Wii, it is possible to copy files between the console and a computer without them being formatted to something unreadable by a PC. They then found the game file on the system and did a little digging.

The simplest way of getting old games to work on modern systems or consoles, is for the manufacturer to dump the ROM code from a cartridge, and then create an emulator that can play this ROM code. It’s no different from copying discs back in the day. The only difference is that due to the way cartridges were made, and the dumping process itself, every single cartridge dump will be slightly different. They won’t be visible in any way through what is produced, but by exploring with a hex editor it is possible to see these differences in the way they have been translated.

It’s here were things get interesting. Due to the fact it is so incredibly unlikely to get two rom dumps that are the same, you would expect Nintendo’s version of Super Mario Bros to be different to any that are being pirated on rom websites online, considering it came out after those ones were put up for download. However they are exactly the same. The only conclusion to this is that Nintendo just downloaded the pirated version and sold it themselves. We have reached out to Nintendo UK to see if they can explain why this would be the case, but at the time of writing we haven’t heard anything back.

What do you guys think about this story? Join in with the conversation in the comments below, or like our Facebook page for more great content.

Related posts

Japanese Developers Speak Out About the Nintendo Switch

Japanese Developers Speak Out About the Nintendo Switch

SEGA, Capcom, Grasshopper Manufacture, Level-5, PlatinumGames and more give their opinions on the Nintendo Switch.

Why the Snes Playstation Pictures are Fake

Why the Snes Playstation Pictures are Fake

The Snes Playstation pictures have been floating around the web recently. Here's why we feel the prototype is fake.

WWE 2K15 Roster – 20 Confirmed Playable Superstars

WWE 2K15 Roster - 20 Confirmed Playable Superstars

The WWE series of games, like most sport franchise, is heavily dependent on a decent roster to sell units. Especially considering the gameplay barely changes year after year. As we near the October 2014 release date of WWE 2K15, we're beginning to learn who's in and who's out. Released...

GTA V Modding Issues

GTA V Modding Issues

It appears that modders have gotten their claws code into Grand Theft Auto V, modding the game for less than wholesome fun. Warning: NSFW. Trigger Warning: Rape. GTA V isn't known to be family friendly with sexual escapades. Even online play was recently updated to allow players to engage...

Transformable Optimus Prime/PS1, Megatron/Megadrive

Transformable Optimus Prime/PS1, Megatron/Megadrive

Sony Japan and Asia has just announced a new line of products, in collaboration with toy manufacturer Takara Tomy. Most of the line consists of scaled down miniature versions Playstation models, including the PS2, the PS3 and the PS4. More interestingly, the line also features an Optimus...

NewsBite 21/08/14 – “Quinspiracy” and Accusations of Corruption

NewsBite 21/08/14 - "Quinspiracy" and Accusations of Corruption

Vince takes a look at this weeks biggest news story and its ramifications on the wider video gaming press and communities. Be warned, he has strong opinions as always on the topic, as well as the industry and associated community's reactions to the "Quinnspiracy"...

E3 Nintendo Hype – News

E3 Nintendo Hype - News

Thanks to E3 I am buying a WiiU. I've been on the fence about which new console to buy, but now Nintendo has gotten me so excited for the coming year in gaming. Sure, of all the games they announced at E3, only about 3 of them are actually new IPs, but Nintendo are going out of their way to...

Civilization Online – This Is Not What I’m Used To

Civilization Online - This Is Not What I'm Used To

Civilization Online doesn't look like a traditional Civilization game.

UPDATED – Hacker Group Takes Down DOTA 2, LoL, Battle.net, and PhantomL0rd Gets Arrested

UPDATED - Hacker Group Takes Down DOTA 2, LoL, Battle.net, and PhantomL0rd Gets Arrested

Cyber attacks are swiftly becoming a common nuisance in the life of a gamer. This most recent one was something special. Surely you will remember the massive Playstation Network security breach at the hands of LulzSec that resulted in the leaking of thousands of passwords back in 2011? If...

3 Comments

  1. avatar
    Jay January 20, 2017
    Reply

    …So we’re supposed to get angry at Nintendo for charging money for a product they created…?

    Clickbait!

    Also- “They would of course be perfectly legally allowed to do this – it is still their product after all” now compare this to the title.
    …So, fake news as well…?

    • Profile photo of Jordan
      Jordan January 20, 2017
      Reply

      We aren’t angry – its a discussion point. And the ROM was illegally made and uploaded, hence the title.

      • avatar
        P February 7, 2017
        Reply

        Interesting Ethical quandary!

        Is it then morally (never mind legally, because it used to be illegal to be a homosexual so the law isn’t always a good moral barometer) acceptable to download Roms if Nintendo themselves do so?

        Someone at Nintendo must have gone to a Rom site on the web and downloaded the same Rom so called Pirates similarly downloaded. And then uploaded it to the virtual store for profit, the only defining difference being that person who pirated it followed the same procedure as Nintendo just without then buying it on the virtual store. And as the president of the United States teaches us, not paying for something and still obtaining it, makes you “smart”… (sarcasm)

        I genuinely think acts like this on behalf of the big N only further legitimize the free Rom market place over their virtual console.

        What do you guys & girls think?

Leave a Reply